Appstle Loyalty vs Memberply

An Appstle Loyalty alternative for membership benefits

Compare the complete reward journey, from earning points to using a benefit. Choose the program and customer experience that fit your store.

Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.

This is a Memberply product comparison, not an independent review. Provider sources are linked below.

Illustrative reward journey worksheet with earning, redemption and repeat-benefit checks

Trusted by Shopify merchants

Appstle Loyalty and Appstle Memberships are different products

This page compares Appstle Loyalty, the points and rewards app, with Memberply. If you are choosing a tool to sell paid membership plans from Appstle’s portfolio, use our Appstle Memberships comparison instead. A VIP reward tier is not automatically a recurring paid subscription.

Consider Memberply when you want free or paid membership tiers with benefits such as discounts, shipping perks, store credit and selected member access. Appstle Loyalty remains a strong candidate when its points rules, cart or checkout redemption and connected Appstle setup meet your needs.

Start with the change you want: a new membership offer, a different redemption journey or a simpler benefit setup. Changing apps without a clear requirement can create migration work without improving the customer experience.

Appstle Loyalty vs Memberply: compare the journey

On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.

Loyalty and membership requirements
RequirementAppstle LoyaltyMemberply
Program focusPoints, store credit, referrals and VIP rewards, with Appstle portfolio integrations.Free, recurring and one-time membership tiers with configurable benefits.
POS points redemptionEarn and redeem points at Shopify POS from Starter.POS displays member rewards; point redemption happens in the member area.
VIP and rewardsBusiness adds VIP, point-expiry settings and free-product redemption.Benefits attach to selected membership tiers. Check the eligibility and renewal rules you need.
Checkout experienceBusiness Premium lists checkout points redemption for Shopify Plus.Points are redeemed in the member area, not assumed to be the same inline checkout flow.
Paid membership setupLoyalty integrates with the separate Appstle Memberships product; confirm the combined workflow and plan cost.Membership billing and benefits are configured in Memberply, using supported Shopify payment workflows.

Source: Appstle Loyalty’s official listing. Review Memberply reward points and test your store’s customer-account experience before choosing.

Appstle Loyalty pricing and Memberply’s app fee

The following are Appstle Loyalty’s published monthly USD prices, not Appstle Memberships prices. Confirm the applicable tier when your store approaches an order threshold; annual and negotiated plans differ.

On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.

Published Appstle Loyalty monthly plans
PlanMonthly feeOrder allowance
Free$0Up to 250 orders
Starter$10500-order threshold
Business$302,000-order threshold
Business Premium$1005,000 orders, then $0.015 per additional order
Enterprise$30020,000 orders, then $0.015 per additional order
Enterprise PlusCustomUnlimited; confirm the agreed scope

The listing offers 14-day trials on the paid plans. The vendor pricing page also lists Enterprise and Enterprise Plus; confirm developer requirements and the agreed scope. Check the Shopify listing and Appstle’s full pricing table.

Memberply Growth is US$49/month for standard membership features. Advanced is US$149/month and adds API access. Both offer a 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions. Memberply charges no percentage of membership revenue; Shopify and payment-provider fees, taxes and the benefits you fund are separate. Compare Memberply plans.

Illustrative comparison: if Appstle Loyalty Business meets your requirements, its $30 monthly fee is $19 below Memberply Growth. At 6,000 counted orders, Business Premium’s listed formula gives $100 + (1,000 × $0.015) = $115. These are app-fee examples, not claims that the plans deliver identical capabilities.

Add any separate membership or subscription app, integration charges and funded rewards to your budget. If you already pay for an Appstle bundle, compare your actual renewal quote, not the sum of unrelated list prices.

Test what the customer actually receives

In Memberply, points redemption issues Shopify store credit for new customer accounts or a discount code for legacy accounts. It requires an action in the member area; signing in alone does not convert points. Native store credit must be enabled when using that account experience.

For example, a fictional program could use 100 points per $1 of credit. A member redeeming $5 spends 500 points and receives $5 of credit, not a $500 reward. Check the currency, issued amount and remaining balance in your trial.

The expiry configured for this Memberply benefit applies to the credit or discount code issued on redemption, not the points balance. If your current program expires unredeemed points, treat that as a separate requirement. Do not assume Appstle’s point-expiry setting maps directly to Memberply credit expiry.

A five-step trial before you move

  1. Create one representative benefit

    Use a tier, eligible purchase and reward value that match the planned offer. Write down excluded products and any stacking rules.

  2. Earn and redeem as a customer

    Check the account area on mobile, the points calculation and the issued credit or code. Repeat the process with the account type your store actually uses.

  3. Test in-store behaviour

    If you use Shopify POS, check how staff identify the member and how the member redeems. Do not treat a displayed balance as proof of POS-native point redemption.

  4. Review connected messages

    Check the welcome and benefit messages against the actual balance and account links. Replace old links and avoid sending duplicate reward notifications.

  5. Confirm the billing boundary

    If paid memberships are part of the change, test joining, renewal and cancellation separately from ordinary loyalty earning and redemption.

Separate members, rewards and subscriptions when switching

Inventory customers, points, issued rewards, tier status, expiry settings and connected automations before changing apps. Record the old reward obligation and agree how each item will be handled; a new member record does not recreate an existing coupon or point balance.

Memberply imports up to 500 member records per CSV. Importing does not transfer payment mandates, create subscription contracts or cancel old billing. A separate payment-setup checkout may charge immediately, so agree the cutover date before inviting members.

Pilot a small group, reconcile the results and keep a record of exceptions before removing old widgets or workflows. Use the loyalty migration checklist or compare other Shopify loyalty options.

Appstle Loyalty alternative FAQs

Is this about Appstle Loyalty or Appstle Memberships?

This page compares Appstle Loyalty, the points and rewards app. Appstle Memberships is a separate product for membership programs and has its own Memberply comparison.

Is Memberply cheaper than Appstle Loyalty?

Not on every plan. Appstle Loyalty offers free, US$10 and US$30 monthly plans, while Memberply Growth is US$49/month. Compare the features, order allowance and any companion apps your program needs.

Can Memberply members redeem points directly in Shopify POS?

Memberply POS displays rewards, but point redemption takes place in the member area. Test this customer and staff workflow before replacing a POS-native points redemption setup.

Does Memberply credit expiry mean the points expire?

No. The expiry configured for the reward-points benefit applies to the credit or discount code issued when points are redeemed, not to the points balance itself.

Does a Memberply import move existing subscriptions?

No. It imports supported membership records, not payment mandates or subscription contracts. Plan payment setup and cancellation of previous billing separately.

Merchant reviews

Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs

Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.

★★★★★

"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."

Olverum Official Store

United Kingdom

★★★★★

"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."

Puzzery

Canada

★★★★★

"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."

Elemental Outfit AR

Argentina

Test the reward journey with Memberply

Start with one membership tier and one useful benefit. Check earning, redemption and renewal during your eligible 14-day trial.

Install on Shopify