Joy Loyalty vs Memberply
A Joy Loyalty alternative for Shopify memberships
Choose the membership workflow your team wants to run. Compare Joy’s connected loyalty and subscription setup with Memberply’s membership tiers, benefits and renewal workflow.
Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.
This is a Memberply product comparison, not an independent review. Provider sources are linked below.

Trusted by Shopify merchants
When does Memberply make sense?
Memberply is an alternative to Joy Loyalty when the main job is running free or paid membership tiers with recurring benefits, member discounts and access. Joy already supports paid memberships: this decision is about the setup, features and costs that suit your store.
Keep Joy on your shortlist if its points program, wallet passes, social rewards or existing subscription integrations are central to your customer experience. A working loyalty program is valuable; list the specific problem you need to solve before replacing it.
For a fictional coffee club, the requirement might be a monthly membership with a shipping perk and recurring store credit. Test how each app starts the membership, grants benefits after payment and handles cancellation. Those steps matter more than the number of features in a comparison table.
Joy Loyalty vs Memberply
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Requirement | Joy Loyalty | Memberply |
|---|---|---|
| Paid memberships | Advanced and above advertise paid memberships. Connect Joy Subscription or a supported third-party subscription workflow. | Free, recurring and one-time membership tiers with benefits managed in Memberply. |
| Recurring billing setup | Joy Subscription connection uses membership plans and a subscription widget. The third-party route uses Shopify Flow for lifecycle updates. | Configure the membership tier and Shopify selling plan, then test purchase, renewal and cancellation. |
| Program benefits | Points, referrals and tier benefits; availability depends on plan. Wallet passes and POS extension are Advanced features. | Member discounts, shipping benefits, points, store credit and selected member-access benefits. Verify each intended workflow. |
| Referrals | Verify the reward and friend-offer configuration you need. | Active eligible members earn points or credit; the referred friend gets no automatic referral discount. |
| API requirements | Developer toolkit and API are listed on Ultimate. | Memberply API access requires Advanced or Enterprise. |
Sources: Joy’s plan comparison and Joy Subscription setup. For a third-party billing app, review Joy’s Shopify Flow setup.
Compare the complete membership setup cost
Joy’s published monthly USD plans are shown below. Order allowances refer to Joy’s plan usage rules, not the number of paid members. Confirm which orders count and any existing contract terms.
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Plan | Base fee and included monthly orders | Additional usage |
|---|---|---|
| Starter | $0; 250 orders | Confirm eligibility and upgrade rules. |
| Essential | $29; 500 orders | $15 per additional 100 orders. |
| Advanced | $129; 2,000 orders | $10 per additional 100 orders. |
| Ultimate | $499; 7,000 orders | $5 per additional 100 orders. |
Memberply Growth is US$49/month for standard membership features. Advanced is US$149/month and adds API access. Both offer a 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions. Memberply charges no percentage of membership revenue; Shopify and payment-provider fees, taxes and the benefits you fund are separate. Compare Memberply plans.
Illustrative app-fee example: at 2,500 counted orders, Joy Advanced is $129 + (5 × $10) = $179/month. Memberply Growth is $49/month. This compares published app fees, not identical capabilities; Memberply Advanced is $149 if your project needs its API.
Joy’s subscription setup guide advertises a complimentary Joy Subscription Advanced upgrade for eligible Joy Loyalty Advanced merchants. Confirm the combined-plan offer with Joy rather than adding an assumed second fee. Include any other paid integrations, reward funding and migration work in your budget. Check current Joy pricing.
Test the membership lifecycle before switching
Join as a new member
Create one sample tier with the actual price and benefit rules you intend to sell. Complete checkout using the customer account experience your store uses.
Use a benefit
Test the discount, credit or shipping perk on an eligible basket and an excluded basket. Make the terms understandable in the welcome message.
Renew and cancel
Check the renewal workflow, failed-payment handling and when benefits end after cancellation. Confirm the same outcome in every connected app.
Check the member experience
Open the account area on mobile. Confirm the member can find benefits and understand their next payment or expiry without contacting support.
Move membership records and payments separately
Before leaving Joy, inventory paid members, points, issued rewards, expiry dates, subscription contracts and live automations. An exported customer row does not transfer a payment agreement or recreate a reward.
Memberply imports up to 500 membership records per CSV. Importing can grant benefits, but it does not create a Shopify subscription or transfer payment mandates. A separate payment setup checkout may charge immediately; agree the timing before inviting members. The old subscription is not cancelled automatically.
Pilot with a small agreed group, reconcile balances and access, then schedule the cutover. Stop duplicate messages and rewards only after you have verified the replacement journey. Use the migration checklist.
Joy Loyalty alternative FAQs
Does Joy Loyalty support paid memberships?
Yes. Joy lists paid membership programs on Advanced and above, with setup through Joy Subscription or a connected subscription workflow. Compare the lifecycle and combined-plan terms before switching.
Is Memberply always cheaper than Joy?
No. Joy offers a free plan and a lower-priced Essential plan. Memberply Growth is US$49/month. Compare the features, counted order volume, integrations and benefits your program requires.
Can I move Joy subscriptions with a Memberply CSV import?
No. Memberply CSV imports move supported membership records, not subscription contracts or payment mandates. Plan payment setup separately and verify it before cancelling existing billing.
Does Memberply offer every Joy feature?
Do not assume feature parity. Check your required wallet, social reward, checkout, referral and integration workflows individually before replacing Joy.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Test your paid membership journey
Build one membership tier and check the complete customer journey during your eligible 14-day trial.
Install on Shopify