Okendo Loyalty vs Memberply

An Okendo Loyalty alternative for Shopify memberships

Decide which parts of your loyalty program should change and which should stay. Compare member benefits, customer journeys and the complete cost of switching.

Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.

This is a Memberply product comparison, not an independent review. Provider sources are linked below.

Illustrative loyalty shortlist worksheet covering program rules, total cost, migration and tools to retain

Trusted by Shopify merchants

Compare the loyalty product, not the whole Okendo platform

Memberply is worth considering when you want to run free or paid membership tiers with benefits such as store credit, discounts, shipping perks and selected member access. This is a comparison with Okendo Loyalty, not a claim that Memberply replaces Okendo Reviews, Quizzes, Surveys or its entire platform.

Okendo already advertises paid memberships in early access alongside points, perks, store credit and VIP tiers. Its setup guide describes Shopify recurring billing without a separate subscription tool. Active Okendo Loyalty and account-manager confirmation of early-access eligibility are required. Compare the offer your store can use today.

Keep Okendo on your shortlist if its loyalty displays, reward rules, reporting or connections to your existing tools are important. If reviews are working well, there may be no reason to move them as part of a loyalty decision. First identify which modules and automations depend on the loyalty data.

Okendo Loyalty vs Memberply

On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.

Requirements to verify in a trial
RequirementOkendo LoyaltyMemberply
Program modelPoints, perks, store credit and VIP tiers; eligible early-access memberships use Shopify recurring billing.Free, recurring and one-time membership tiers with configurable member benefits.
Customer reward journeyLoyalty displays and customer-account modules support balance visibility and reward redemption. Loyalty checkout extensions require Shopify Plus and checkout extensibility.Members redeem points in their member area to native credit with new customer accounts or a code with legacy accounts.
In-store useShopify POS integration advertises earning points and redeeming rewards.POS displays membership benefits and rewards; point redemption happens in the member area.
CommunicationsLoyalty data can support native updates and integrations such as Klaviyo.Member communications and integrations are available; verify the exact event, field and message needed.
Broader product suiteReviews, Quizzes, Surveys and Referrals are separately identified products and may be bundled.This comparison covers membership functionality, not replacement of those other product categories.

Source: Okendo’s loyalty feature overview. For Memberply, review points redemption and Klaviyo membership data. Also review Okendo’s membership setup and checkout-extension requirements.

Compare your actual Okendo scope with Memberply plans

Okendo’s pricing page offers products, bundles and platform packages, with choices based on monthly order volume. Obtain the current price for your exact loyalty scope and any early-access membership requirements. Do not compare a whole-platform quote with a single-app fee and call the difference a saving.

On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.

Questions for an accurate cost comparison
Cost itemWhat to confirm
Loyalty subscriptionSelected order band, contract length, renewal terms and any additional usage charges.
Paid membershipsEarly-access add-on eligibility and fees; confirm the shipping or discount setup in Shopify or supporting apps.
Products you retainThe price of Reviews, Quizzes, Surveys or Referrals after changing the bundle.
ImplementationMigration assistance, custom displays, integrations and ongoing support.
Funded rewardsThe discounts, credit and other benefits your store promises to honour.

Use Okendo’s current pricing options to request the correct package. No numerical Okendo savings claim is made here.

Memberply Growth is US$49/month for standard membership features. Advanced is US$149/month and adds API access. Both offer a 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions. Memberply charges no percentage of membership revenue; Shopify and payment-provider fees, taxes and the benefits you fund are separate. Compare Memberply plans.

A useful budgeting formula is: new membership app + retained tools + integration costs + migration work. Compare that with the actual cost of keeping your current setup. Reward funding belongs in both budgets.

Illustrative reward obligation: 150 members receiving $4 in credit creates $600 of issued credit. That amount is separate from the software bill and is not itself a measure of cash cost or profit. Check expected redemption and product margin before changing the offer.

Keep useful tools and check their dependencies

List the customer-facing components you use today: review forms, loyalty pages, account modules, points previews, email blocks and POS screens. Assign an owner to each one. Keeping a review app does not guarantee that an old points incentive or loyalty email will still work after its connected loyalty product is removed.

For a fictional apparel store, the project might retain its review collection while moving a paid club’s benefits. Test the review request independently from the new member welcome. Remove obsolete points promises from emails and check that every reward link leads to the right account area.

Tell members what changes in plain language: which benefits remain, where their balance appears and how to get help. A clear transition is more useful than a new program name without an explanation.

Use acceptance checks before signing off

  1. Confirm the membership offer

    Set the price, renewal interval, benefits and cancellation policy. If evaluating Okendo paid memberships, confirm early-access eligibility and the supported journey with Okendo.

  2. Test one reward from start to finish

    Make an eligible purchase, inspect the earned balance and redeem it. Check the issued credit or code, its expiry and the remaining balance.

  3. Check different customer states

    Try an active member, a non-member and a cancelled or expired member. Verify benefit access without assuming that every app uses the same status definitions.

  4. Exercise the connected tools

    Review one actual email, customer-account flow and POS journey where applicable. Confirm required data fields and events rather than relying on an integration logo.

  5. Agree on migration sign-off

    Choose who reconciles imported members, outstanding rewards and billing. Keep an exception list and resolve it before ending the old workflow.

Treat reward balances and payment agreements separately

Okendo documents separate customer-profile and loyalty-transaction exports. Profiles can include points, pending points, VIP status and membership status. Obtain both where needed and reconcile them before mapping records into a new system. Preserve the value already promised to customers; changing a tier name does not settle outstanding rewards.

Memberply accepts up to 500 member records per CSV. A membership import does not automatically transfer point balances, issued rewards, payment mandates or subscription contracts. It also does not cancel old billing. Payment setup through a separate checkout may charge immediately, so coordinate member communications and billing dates.

Start with a small agreed sample and verify the destination member experience. Follow the migration checklist and review Okendo’s export fields. For a project needing custom integrations or hands-on implementation, discuss the requirements before committing to a cutover date.

Okendo Loyalty alternative FAQs

Does Okendo offer paid memberships?

Okendo’s loyalty page advertises paid memberships in early access. Its setup guide uses Shopify recurring billing without a separate subscription tool. Confirm eligibility and applicable add-on terms with Okendo.

Can Memberply replace the entire Okendo platform?

This comparison does not claim that. Memberply is a membership option; Okendo also offers products such as reviews, quizzes and surveys. Evaluate each required product separately.

How much would I save by switching from Okendo?

That depends on your actual Okendo package, retained products, implementation needs and benefit costs. Memberply Growth is US$49/month and Advanced is US$149/month; those fees alone do not establish net savings.

Can I keep a reviews tool when changing loyalty apps?

Evaluate that separately. Check the remaining subscription terms, review incentives and any connected loyalty data or emails. Keeping one product does not automatically preserve every integration.

Will Memberply import Okendo rewards and subscriptions automatically?

Do not assume automatic transfer. Memberply imports supported membership records. Rewards, points, payment agreements and subscription contracts need separate migration checks.

Merchant reviews

Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs

Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.

★★★★★

"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."

Olverum Official Store

United Kingdom

★★★★★

"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."

Puzzery

Canada

★★★★★

"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."

Elemental Outfit AR

Argentina

Build a membership trial around your requirements

Choose one tier and a clear benefit. Test the customer journey and retained tools before moving your existing loyalty program.

Install on Shopify