A Yotpo Loyalty alternative for Shopify memberships
Compare points, tier rules, membership benefits and app costs. See when Memberply fits your loyalty program and what to check before moving from Yotpo.
Memberply Growth: US$49/month. Unlimited members. 14-day free trial.
This comparison explains Memberply’s perspective and links to both providers’ sources. It is not an independent review.
Match the replacement to your loyalty program
Memberply is a Yotpo Loyalty alternative to evaluate when you want a free or paid membership with configured benefits, including purchase points, credit, discounts and shipping perks. Start with how customers join and use the offer, then compare the software.
This page covers Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals. Memberply is not a replacement for a product-review collection and display system. If you also use Yotpo Reviews, evaluate that service and any review-to-reward connections separately.
Yotpo’s listing describes points campaigns, referrals, VIP tiers and integrations such as Klaviyo and Recharge. Keep it on your shortlist when those workflows are important. Read Yotpo’s App Store listing.
Compare earning, eligibility and redemption
| Requirement | Yotpo Loyalty | Memberply |
|---|---|---|
| Earning points | Map the purchase and engagement campaigns you currently use, including any review rewards. | Members can earn purchase points and redeem them for credit. Do not assume every engagement campaign has an equivalent. |
| Tier eligibility | Current Loyalty Tiers documentation describes spend, points, purchase-count and customer-tag criteria. Check the program version. | Configure membership tiers with free or paid access. Verify any required automatic promotion, demotion and qualification period separately. |
| Member benefits | Check the rewards and tier perks included in your selected plan. | Bundle documented benefits such as store credit, discounts and shipping. Test eligibility and exclusions for your offer. |
| Connected workflows | The listing includes Shopify Flow, Klaviyo, Recharge and POS. Confirm plan access and behavior. | Compare exact Klaviyo fields, webhook events and POS journeys. A shared integration name does not establish feature parity. |
Sources: Yotpo’s listing and current Loyalty Tiers documentation.
A paid membership and an earned tier are different offers
An earned tier recognizes behavior over a qualification period. A paid membership sells access to a benefit bundle. A free membership can provide access without a fee. Decide which promise you want customers to understand before comparing similarly named tier features.
Yotpo documents newer Loyalty Tiers separately from legacy VIP Tiers, with August 11, 2025 as an onboarding boundary. Its legacy documentation includes paid membership access. Do not assume that all Yotpo programs have the same setup, or that paid access is unique to Memberply. Confirm your program version and supported route. Sources: current Loyalty Tiers and legacy VIP Tiers.
Illustrative example: a skincare store wants to recognize repeat shoppers with points, while a paid tier offers shipping benefits. Write separate rules for points earning and paid access. Check what happens after a refund, cancellation or missed renewal, rather than assuming the two statuses always change together. This is a planning example, not a customer result.
Compare Yotpo Loyalty pricing with Memberply Growth
| Plan | Published price | What to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Yotpo Free | US$0; the App Store listing limits eligibility to fewer than 100 monthly orders | Check eligibility and whether its included features are enough. |
| Yotpo Pro | Starts at US$199/month | The website includes 500 orders, then lists tiered per-order charges. The App Store describes a different rate range; confirm your actual offer. |
| Yotpo Premium / Enterprise | Custom quote | The website places VIP tiers and POS in Premium. Request a quote for your required setup. |
| Memberply Growth | US$49/month; unlimited members; 14-day trial | Confirm that the standard membership benefits meet your needs. Reward funding and Shopify/payment fees are separate. |
Sources: Yotpo website pricing, Yotpo App Store pricing and Memberply pricing.
Yotpo’s website shows Pro order bands of US$0.20 for orders 501-1,000, US$0.10 for 1,001-3,000 and US$0.05 for 3,001-10,000. Its App Store listing instead describes US$0.08-US$0.20 per order from 500 orders. Confirm which schedule applies before budgeting.
Illustrative calculation using the website schedule: at 800 monthly orders, US$199 + (300 × US$0.20) = US$259. That is US$210 above Memberply Growth’s app fee. It is not a feature-equivalent quote or guaranteed saving. Include implementation, other tools and the benefits you fund.
When to keep Yotpo, and when to trial Memberply
Keep Yotpo on your shortlist if your program depends on engagement campaigns, earned-tier rules or connected workflows you have already validated. A free plan can also be sufficient for an eligible small store. Rebuilding a working reward program has a cost.
Trial Memberply if the offer centers on membership access and benefits that its standard features support. Validate purchase points, credit redemption and membership management together. Memberply’s points expiry setting controls credit created by redemption; do not treat it as proof of identical point-balance expiry behavior.
Memberply’s new customer account experience uses native store credit when enabled. Its legacy member dashboard uses the documented discount-code flow. Test the account experience your store uses, including currency and any in-store redemption requirements. Review the reward-points documentation.
Move reward value, not just a customer list
Inventory rules and balances
Record points, issued coupons, available credit, tier qualification dates, expiry terms and pending referrals. Map the messages and integrations that read those values.
Preserve the value customers were promised
Illustrative case: 1,000 old points redeem for US$10. If the new program needs 200 points per dollar, copying the number 1,000 would give only US$5. Agree the conversion and terms before moving balances, and avoid leaving duplicate rewards spendable.
Separate member import from program migration
Memberply’s CSV member import supports up to 500 records per file. It does not establish automatic transfer of Yotpo points, coupons, tier history or payment arrangements. Confirm a migration plan before ending the existing service.
Test a defined cutover
Use approved test customers to verify earning, redemption, tier access and connected messages. Agree when the old program stops issuing rewards and how outstanding obligations will be honored.
Use the loyalty migration guide and member import documentation to scope the work.
Use the trial to answer four buying questions
Can customers join the intended offer?
Build one real tier with its actual eligibility, billing frequency and benefits.
Can members earn and use the right reward?
Follow a purchase through points redemption and checkout. Test an active member, a non-member and an ended membership.
Do the required workflows still work?
Check the exact fields and events used by email, support, reviews and POS. Keep any missing requirement visible in the decision.
Does the complete budget make sense?
Compare app charges, funded benefits and migration effort. A 14-day trial can establish setup fit, not long-term retention lift.
Yotpo Loyalty alternative questions
Is Memberply a Yotpo Loyalty alternative?
Yes, for membership and reward programs that fit Memberply’s standard features. Compare earning rules, tier eligibility, redemption and connected workflows before switching.
Does Memberply replace Yotpo Reviews?
No. This comparison concerns loyalty and membership rewards. Review collection, display and review-to-reward workflows need a separate assessment.
Does Yotpo support paid memberships?
Yotpo’s legacy VIP documentation includes paid membership access. Its newer Loyalty Tiers program has separate documentation. Confirm availability and implementation for your program version.
Is Memberply always cheaper than Yotpo?
No. Yotpo has a free option for eligible stores. Memberply Growth costs US$49 per month. Compare the plan and complete feature set you need, plus migration and reward costs.
Can I automatically transfer Yotpo points and tiers?
Do not assume automatic transfer. Member records, reward value, issued coupons, qualification history and payment arrangements need separate verification and reconciliation.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Test your membership offer in Memberply
Start a 14-day trial or contact us with your requirements. Compare more options in our Shopify loyalty app guide.
Install on Shopify