Marsello vs Memberply
A Marsello alternative for Shopify membership benefits
Build the membership experience your Shopify customers need, online and in store. Compare benefits, staff workflows and the full cost before switching.
Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.
This is a Memberply product comparison, not an independent review. Provider sources are linked below.

Trusted by Shopify merchants
When is Memberply a suitable Marsello alternative?
Consider Memberply when your main requirement is a free or paid Shopify membership program with benefits such as member discounts, shipping perks, points or store credit. Start with the member experience you want to deliver and test it in the channels where you sell.
Marsello combines loyalty with marketing tools and integrations across retail systems. Keep it on your shortlist if your program depends on its POS reward redemption, wallet cards, email/SMS campaigns or connections outside Shopify. This comparison does not claim that Memberply replaces that entire setup.
A fictional homeware store might want a paid club with a member discount and recurring credit. A retailer using several POS platforms and one shared marketing system has a different requirement. Define which case describes your business before comparing app fees.
Marsello vs Memberply: compare the customer and staff journey
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Requirement | Marsello | Memberply |
|---|---|---|
| Program scope | Loyalty and referrals, with optional marketing and SMS tools. | Free, recurring and one-time membership tiers with configurable benefits. |
| In-store rewards | Shopify POS extension lets staff find the customer, inspect available rewards and apply rewards or email discounts. | POS displays membership benefits and rewards. Point redemption takes place in the member area, not directly in POS. |
| Customer benefits | Points and reward rules; advanced conditions and VIP features depend on plan. | Member discounts, shipping benefits, points and store credit can be attached to selected tiers. |
| Email and SMS | Campaign and automation tools are available within Marsello’s broader offering. | Verify member emails and any connected marketing platform separately. Do not assume a replacement for Marsello campaigns or SMS. |
| Other sales systems | Evaluate the supported integration for every system you use. | This comparison covers Memberply for Shopify; it does not establish support for your non-Shopify POS systems. |
Sources: Marsello’s product overview and its Shopify POS reward workflow. Review Memberply POS and Memberply point redemption before deciding.
Count connected sites before comparing prices
Marsello’s published starting prices below are monthly USD amounts. Its site definition includes physical locations and the online store. An online store plus one physical location therefore counts as two sites under the documented example. Confirm your actual connection count and contract.
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Plan | One site | Additional site |
|---|---|---|
| Loyalty Launch | From $60/month | $60/month |
| Loyalty Accelerate | From $120/month | $120/month |
| Enterprise | Custom quote | Confirm the agreed scope |
Launch provides the basic loyalty offer. Accelerate adds features such as VIP tiers, points expiry, advanced reward conditions and API access. Published fair-use bases are 25,000 monthly orders for Launch and 50,000 for Accelerate. Marsello offers a 14-day trial; confirm the terms for your business. Review the current plan comparison.
Memberply Growth is US$49/month for standard membership features. Advanced is US$149/month and adds API access. Both offer a 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions. Memberply charges no percentage of membership revenue; Shopify and payment-provider fees, taxes and the benefits you fund are separate. Compare Memberply plans.
Illustrative site-cost example: one online store and one physical location gives a Marsello Launch starting fee of 2 × $60 = $120/month, or Accelerate at 2 × $120 = $240/month, before add-ons and other charges. Memberply Growth’s published app fee is $49/month. Those figures do not establish equivalent features or net savings.
Marsello lists Marketing from $15/month and SMS separately by usage. Include the cost of any email/SMS service you would retain or add after switching, plus implementation, reward funding and applicable taxes. Ask about your exact setup if you have multiple Shopify stores; do not assume one Memberply subscription covers separate stores. Read Marsello’s site and add-on definitions.
Run a realistic Shopify POS trial
Identify the customer
Have staff add the correct customer to a sale and check the expected membership or loyalty profile. Include an eligible member and a non-member.
Try the intended reward
In Marsello, follow the documented Scan, redeem loyalty rewards workflow. In Memberply, test the member-area points redemption and resulting reward separately from the POS display.
Verify the account experience
Memberply points redeem to native Shopify store credit with new customer accounts, or a discount code with legacy accounts. Check the account type, enabled credit settings and where the customer can use the issued reward.
Check the basket and staff instructions
Test an eligible basket, an excluded product and the discount combinations you intend to allow. Give staff a short process for locating benefits and handling exceptions.
Test membership changes
Check the result after cancellation or expiry. If a benefit should remain until the paid period ends, confirm the configured behaviour before promising it to customers.
Do not infer checkout compatibility from a displayed balance. Your acceptance test should follow the customer all the way from identification to a completed order. For more options, compare Shopify POS loyalty apps.
Keep useful marketing workflows working
List every active campaign, customer segment, wallet link and automated message that uses Marsello data. Decide which you will retain, rebuild or retire. Membership emails do not automatically replace a general email/SMS marketing program.
For example, a fictional store may send a points reminder and a separate welcome message for paid club members. After a change, each message must show the correct benefit, account link and terms. Remove obsolete points claims and avoid issuing or announcing the same reward twice.
Check the fields and events your marketing platform needs, along with customer consent and unsubscribe handling. A customer export alone is not proof that campaigns, consent records or suppression settings have transferred. Plan the integration requirements before disconnecting the old system.
A controlled migration from Marsello
Inventory the source records
Confirm available export fields with Marsello. Record customers, balances, issued rewards, tier status, expiry rules, connected sites and active campaigns. Keep points and issued credit or coupons separate.
Map the destination benefits
Choose the Memberply tiers and benefits that match the agreed offer. Document any rule or marketing function that has no direct replacement.
Pilot and reconcile
Use a small agreed group and check balances, eligibility and customer messages. Memberply imports up to 500 supported member records per CSV; do not assume that points or issued rewards transfer automatically.
Handle payments separately
Importing membership records does not transfer payment mandates, create subscriptions or cancel old billing. Separate payment setup may charge immediately, so coordinate dates and customer communication.
Approve the cutover
Verify online and POS journeys, resolve exceptions and confirm the remaining subscription costs. Remove old widgets or automations only after the replacement workflow is ready.
Use the loyalty migration checklist for the complete handover. If the project needs custom integrations or migration assistance, discuss the scope before selecting a launch date.
Marsello alternative FAQs
Is Memberply a replacement for every Marsello feature?
No. Memberply is an option for Shopify membership programs and benefits. Evaluate Marsello’s marketing, wallet, POS and other-platform requirements separately before switching.
How does Marsello count sites?
Marsello’s billing documentation defines sites as sales locations, including physical stores and the online store. Its example counts one physical location plus an online store as two sites. Confirm your actual connections and contract.
Can Memberply redeem points directly in Shopify POS?
Memberply POS displays rewards, but points redemption happens in the member area. Test the resulting credit or code and staff workflow before replacing POS-native reward redemption.
Will switching to Memberply reduce my total cost?
Not necessarily. Compare your actual Marsello sites, plan and add-ons with Memberply, retained marketing services, implementation and funded benefits. A lower app fee alone does not establish net savings.
Can I import all Marsello data into Memberply automatically?
Do not assume automatic transfer. Memberply imports supported membership records in files of up to 500 records. Balances, issued rewards, campaigns, consent records and payment agreements need separate mapping and verification.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Test your Shopify membership experience
Start with one tier and a clear benefit. Test both the customer journey and the staff workflow during your eligible 14-day trial.
Install on Shopify