Locksmith vs Memberply
A Locksmith alternative for Shopify membership access
If access belongs to a free or paid membership, compare the complete journey: joining, using benefits and losing access when eligibility ends.
Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.
This is a Memberply product comparison, not an independent review. Provider sources are linked below.

Trusted by Shopify merchants
When should you consider replacing Locksmith?
Memberply is worth evaluating when membership eligibility should drive access alongside benefits such as discounts or store credit. Locksmith is a dedicated access-control tool with a wider range of lock conditions. Replacing it only makes sense if your actual rules fit the membership workflow.
Keep Locksmith on your shortlist when you rely on passcodes, secret links, location, date-based access or other granular conditions. A member-only collection and a location-specific product lock are different requirements; do not treat them as interchangeable.
If all you need is one simple lock, a membership platform may add unnecessary setup and expense. If you are already combining billing, customer status and access tools, document which system owns each step before deciding what to consolidate.
Map your Locksmith rules to membership requirements
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Requirement | Locksmith | Memberply |
|---|---|---|
| Who gets access | Conditions can include customer tags, sign-in, passcodes, secret links, purchases, location and dates. | Selected benefits and access are based on configured membership eligibility. Do not assume every Locksmith rule has an equivalent. |
| Charging for membership | Evaluate the separate payment or subscription workflow that supplies eligibility. | Free, recurring and one-time membership tiers, with benefits and renewal workflows. |
| Page access | Dedicated store access controls; check your exact resource and theme requirements. | Selected Shopify pages use the Memberply Restricted Pages theme component and a browser-side eligibility check. |
| Product access | Flexible locks for store resources and purchasing conditions; test your configuration. | Exclusive product and collection access require the relevant theme components and storefront testing. |
| Other member benefits | Confirm any companion apps needed for your offer. | Member discounts, shipping benefits, points and store credit can accompany membership access. |
Sources: Locksmith’s official listing, Locksmith documentation and Memberply locked-content access.
Understand what Memberply page restriction protects
Memberply’s page restriction checks eligibility in the visitor’s browser. The page HTML is still delivered, JavaScript must run and the component must be present on the page’s theme template. If the access request fails, the current component reveals the page.
Direct file and video URLs are not protected by this check. Do not use Memberply page restriction alone for confidential information or secure downloads. If those are your requirements, evaluate suitable protected delivery before choosing an app.
Test on the actual storefront outside the theme editor, where the access check is skipped. Verify every template used by restricted pages and keep the redirect destination public to avoid loops. Read the setup and access limitations.
Compare access-only cost with a membership setup
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Shopify plan | Locksmith suggested price | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Basic | $12 | All Locksmith features |
| Grow | $29 | All Locksmith features |
| Advanced | $99 | All Locksmith features |
| Plus | $199 | All Locksmith features |
Locksmith offers a 15-day trial, no usage fees and a “Pay what feels good” pricing policy. These are suggested prices tied to your Shopify plan, not a fixed quote for every merchant. Read Locksmith’s pricing policy.
Memberply Growth is US$49/month for standard membership features. Advanced is US$149/month and adds API access. Both offer a 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions. Memberply charges no percentage of membership revenue; Shopify and payment-provider fees, taxes and the benefits you fund are separate. Compare Memberply plans.
Illustrative example: on Shopify Basic, Locksmith’s suggested $12 app fee is $37 below Memberply Growth. If you only need a lock, lower cost may favour Locksmith. If your requirements include paid membership billing and benefits, compare the full cost and operation of the tools needed to deliver them. Memberply is not automatically the cheaper choice.
Use a lock-by-lock switching checklist
Inventory each existing lock
Record its URL or resource, allowed visitors, condition, redirect and owner. Include temporary access, passcodes and any manually applied tags.
Map the intended membership rule
Choose the destination tier and benefit. Mark any rule that has no equivalent. Keep that rule in an appropriate tool or revise the requirement before switching.
Test all customer states
Try signed-out visitors, signed-in non-members, active members, members in the wrong tier and expired members. Test each applicable page, product and collection template.
Check the full purchase path
Review direct links, search, collection browsing, quick-add, cart and checkout separately. A hidden page is not evidence that every purchase path is blocked.
Verify expiry and payment timing
Test what happens after cancellation, failed payment and access expiry. When importing records, remember that payment mandates and subscription contracts do not transfer automatically.
Cut over without conflicting rules
Pilot before disabling old locks. Check for duplicate redirects or contradictory rules, then verify the customer experience again after removing the old configuration.
Example: a members-only early-access collection
A fictional homeware store wants active club members to view a selected collection before a public launch and receive a member discount. Record the access requirement and the discount requirement separately. Test both with an eligible member and someone whose membership has ended.
If the same store also needs a location-specific restriction or a shared secret link for press previews, evaluate those separately. Do not replace a working Locksmith rule simply because another part of the store is moving to Memberply.
Need a broader comparison? Compare Shopify content-restriction apps. For paid membership costs, use the membership app-fee calculator.
Locksmith alternative FAQs
Can Memberply replace every Locksmith lock?
No. Memberply is a membership option with selected access benefits. Map each existing condition and test it; keep an appropriate access tool when a rule has no supported equivalent.
Does Memberply securely protect private files and videos?
No. Its browser-side page check does not protect direct file or video URLs. HTML is delivered to the browser, and a failed access request reveals the page. Use suitable protected delivery for confidential content.
Is Memberply cheaper than Locksmith?
Not always. Locksmith’s suggested monthly price starts at US$12 for Shopify Basic, while Memberply Growth is US$49. Compare the complete setup if you also need membership billing and benefits.
Can I import members and keep their existing payments?
Memberply can import supported membership records, but the import does not create subscriptions or transfer payment mandates. Plan payment setup and existing billing cancellation separately.
How should I test member-only access?
Use the actual storefront and test signed-out visitors, non-members, eligible members, wrong-tier members and expired members. Check all relevant templates and direct purchase paths before switching.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Try membership access with clear requirements
Start with one tier and one access benefit. Check the storefront behaviour and limitations before moving your existing locks.
Install on Shopify