ReferralCandy vs Memberply
A ReferralCandy alternative for Shopify member referrals
Make referrals part of your membership program. Compare rewards, costs and the customer journey before choosing the right fit.
Memberply Growth: US$49/month. Unlimited members. 14-day free trial.
Published by Memberply, with links to both providers’ sources. This is a fit comparison, not an independent review.

Trusted by Shopify merchants
Choose the referral model you want to run
Memberply is worth considering when active members should invite friends and earn points or store credit. Referrals sit alongside your membership benefits, such as member discounts, shipping perks and recurring credit.
Keep ReferralCandy on your shortlist if you need a broader customer-referral or affiliate program, friend offers, cash rewards or creator commissions. Moving to Memberply changes the referral model; first confirm that your intended participants and rewards fit.
For example, a fictional coffee club could give an active member $10 credit after a friend’s first store purchase qualifies. The friend shops normally, without a referral discount. If your offer is “give a friend 10% off and earn cash,” this Memberply flow does not fit.
Choosing between several tools? Compare Shopify referral apps.
ReferralCandy and Memberply: compare the fit
Start with eligibility and rewards, then compare price. The same “referrals” label does not mean two apps run the same customer journey.
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Requirement | ReferralCandy | Memberply |
|---|---|---|
| Who refers | Customer referral and affiliate campaigns. | Active members in the membership tiers you select. |
| Rewards | Coupons, store credit, cash and gift-card options. | Fixed Memberply points or store credit; no affiliate cash payouts. |
| Friend incentive | Configurable friend offers. | No automatic discount for the referred friend. |
| Qualifying action | Confirm the campaign’s purchase and reward rules. | Choose membership signup or the friend’s first-ever store purchase. |
| Program fit | Dedicated referral and affiliate marketing. | Referrals within a free or paid membership benefit program. |
Sources: ReferralCandy’s Shopify listing, ReferralCandy’s features and pricing and Memberply member referrals. Confirm current terms and your required integrations before subscribing.
Compare app fees and the rewards you fund
Monthly prices below are in USD. The example assumes $2,000 of revenue subject to ReferralCandy’s success fee. It compares app fees only, not equivalent capabilities or expected results.
On smaller screens, scroll the table sideways to compare all columns.
| Plan | Published monthly fee | At $2,000 eligible revenue |
|---|---|---|
| ReferralCandy Basic | $39 + 10.5% success fee | $249 |
| ReferralCandy Grow | $79 + 3.5% success fee | $149 |
| ReferralCandy Scale | $249 + 1.5% success fee | $279 |
| ReferralCandy Enterprise | $799 + 0.25% success fee | $804 |
| Memberply Growth | $49; no Memberply percentage fee | $49 |
ReferralCandy calculates its fee on a new customer’s first three paid orders, using the subtotal after discounts and before tax and shipping. Its plans include a 7-day trial. See the current fee definition and plans.
Memberply Growth includes standard features, unlimited members and a 14-day trial. Review Memberply plans. Shopify/payment-provider charges, reward funding and migration work are separate.
For instance, 20 qualifying referrals with a $10 credit reward create $200 of issued credit. That is a reward obligation, not proof of $200 in cash cost or incremental profit. Check redemption, margin and refunds. At very low referral revenue, ReferralCandy Basic’s app bill can be below Memberply Growth; a lower price alone is not a reason to change a working program.
Check Memberply’s reward timing before switching
Choose one conversion goal
For membership signups, reward on activation or after the friend’s first successful membership payment. Choose payment-based qualification if a free trial should not immediately trigger the reward.
Allow for the first-purchase review
The friend’s first-ever paid store order must qualify. Rewards stay pending for 14 days; cancelled, voided or refunded orders before issuance are disqualified. Later purchases do not earn another first-purchase reward.
Verify attribution and account setup
First-purchase referrals require the Referral tracking theme app embed. Attribution lasts 30 days and the latest valid link wins. Native credit requires Shopify customer accounts and store credit enabled; legacy accounts receive a discount code.
Plan exception handling
Self-referrals and duplicate rewards are blocked. Rewards already delivered are not automatically clawed back after a later refund. Review exceptions before making replacement payments.
Read the member referral setup guide. Enable Reward Points on eligible tiers if choosing points.
A switching checklist for your existing referral program
Record outstanding commitments
List pending and issued rewards, expiry dates, referral links, customer messages and the system responsible for each obligation. Keep an authorized export before changing your current setup.
Map the audience and offer
Decide which active membership tiers can refer and what each conversion earns. Explain any eligibility or friend-offer changes to customers before launch.
Plan links and attribution
Do not assume existing ReferralCandy links, history or pending rewards transfer automatically. Choose a cutoff for old campaigns, update email/storefront links and avoid rewarding the same conversion in both systems.
Pilot one complete journey
Use separate member and friend accounts. Test link attribution, qualification and the account experience. Include a non-member and an existing store customer as negative checks.
Reconcile before closing the old program
Confirm pending obligations, any remaining reward delivery and billing separately. Keep a rollback plan until the new journey works. An app trial is not evidence that historical data or rewards have migrated.
Use the loyalty migration checklist to organize the work, or contact us with your requirements. No automatic ReferralCandy migration is promised.
What to verify during your Memberply trial
Build one tier and a realistic reward. Verify who gets a link, what the friend sees, which action qualifies and how pending rewards appear. For first-purchase referrals, the 14-day review may extend beyond the app trial; arrange to verify final delivery after that period.
Keep a short pass/fail list for your required integrations, reward costs and customer support steps. Install only when the membership model fits; a broader affiliate workflow may be better served by ReferralCandy or another specialist app.
ReferralCandy alternative questions
Is Memberply a ReferralCandy alternative?
Yes, when referrals belong inside a Shopify membership program. Active members in selected tiers can earn points or store credit. Compare eligibility, rewards and connected workflows before switching.
Does Memberply give the referred friend a discount?
No. Memberply rewards the eligible referring member. The friend does not receive an automatic referral discount. Choose a different workflow if both people need an incentive.
Can Memberply pay affiliate cash commissions?
No. Memberply provides member referral rewards in points or store credit, not affiliate cash commissions or creator payout administration.
Can I transfer my ReferralCandy links and rewards automatically?
Do not assume automatic transfer. Existing links, pending rewards, referral history and email journeys need a separate cutover plan. Confirm each requirement before ending your current program.
Is Memberply always cheaper than ReferralCandy?
No. Memberply Growth is US$49/month. ReferralCandy Basic has a lower base fee plus a success fee. Compare the required features, eligible revenue, reward funding and switching costs.
How long do Memberply referral rewards take?
Membership signup rewards can qualify on activation or after the friend’s first successful membership payment. First-store-purchase rewards have a fixed 14-day review period, subject to qualification checks.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Try referrals inside your membership program
Start with a member tier, a clear reward and one customer journey. Memberply Growth includes a 14-day free trial.
Install on Shopify