Appstle Memberships alternative for Shopify paid memberships
Compare Appstle Memberships and Memberply for your Shopify membership program. Review app pricing, member benefits, customer accounts and the checks to make before switching.
Is Memberply a suitable Appstle Memberships alternative?
Memberply is worth evaluating when your offer combines membership tiers with benefits such as store credit, discounts, shipping perks and reward points. Write down the exact benefit rules you need, then test them in the member journey before deciding.
Both apps serve membership programs. This is a comparison published by Memberply, not an independent review or a claim that every merchant should switch. An existing setup that meets your needs may be worth keeping.
Use the Shopify membership app comparison to consider other options, or jump to pricing, costs by program size, features and switching checks.
Appstle Memberships pricing vs Memberply
Compare the monthly app charge and included capacity alongside the features your program needs. The following figures are USD monthly prices shown on the official Shopify App Store listings. Annual billing, custom plans and future pricing changes can differ.
Scroll the table sideways on smaller screens to see every column.
| App and plan | Monthly app price | Member allowance shown |
|---|---|---|
| Appstle Free | $0 | Up to 25 members per month |
| Appstle Starter | $19 | Up to 100 members per month |
| Appstle Business | $39 | Up to 500 members per month |
| Appstle Business Premium | $79 | Up to 750 members per month |
| Memberply Growth | $49 | Unlimited members |
Sources: Appstle Memberships pricing and Memberply pricing. Confirm the plan and how member usage is counted before subscribing.
Memberply offers a 14-day trial and charges no Memberply transaction fee on membership revenue. Shopify and payment-provider charges are separate. Appstle states that its plans have no per-member or hidden fees; review its published billing terms for your setup.
Appstle’s lower-priced plans can cost less than Memberply for a smaller program. Memberply’s unlimited-member allowance may matter as the program grows. These are app-cost comparisons, not like-for-like feature valuations or guarantees of savings.
Budget for the rewards themselves as well as the app. The membership pricing calculator helps model fees, recurring benefit costs and churn.
What does each app cost as your membership grows?
The examples below use Appstle’s lowest listed plan that covers each member allowance and Memberply Growth. They compare monthly USD app subscriptions only. A required feature may put your store on a higher Appstle plan even when its member count is lower.
Scroll the table sideways on smaller screens to see every column.
| Members counted under the plan | Appstle plan and monthly price | Memberply Growth | App-price difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | Free: $0 | $49 | Appstle costs $49 less. |
| 100 | Starter: $19 | $49 | Appstle costs $30 less. |
| 500 | Business: $39 | $49 | Appstle costs $10 less. |
| 750 | Business Premium: $79 | $49 | Memberply costs $30 less. |
The member counts are illustrative and must be matched to Appstle’s usage definition. Above 750, request a current Appstle quote. The figures exclude annual discounts, custom agreements, Shopify charges, payment processing and the benefits you fund.
Memberply’s unlimited-member allowance makes its standard app subscription predictable as the program grows. At the smaller allowances shown here, Appstle has a lower base price. Choose around the complete workflow and required plan, rather than member capacity alone.
Which Appstle plan covers the workflow you need?
The official Appstle listing puts third-party integrations and payment retries on Starter, portal HTML and cancellation management on Business, and custom email domain settings and bulk automations on Business Premium. Enterprise, API and webhook requirements need a direct discussion with Appstle.
If those settings matter to your store, compare the plan containing them even when a cheaper plan has enough member capacity. Memberply Growth includes its standard features; custom integrations and implementation are scoped separately. An integration name in a comparison table is a starting point for a workflow test.
Compare the membership features your store will use
Scroll the table sideways on smaller screens to see every column.
| Workflow | Memberply | Appstle Memberships |
|---|---|---|
| Billing and tiers | Paid, free and one-time tiers, with recurring options for paid memberships. | Plans, recurring billing and configurable billing frequencies. |
| Discounts and shipping | Member discounts and free shipping with configured eligibility. | Discount, shipping and access perks. |
| Credit-based rewards | Cashback, loyalty drops and fee-to-credit support different credit-earning triggers. | Confirm your required credit trigger, redemption and expiry workflow with Appstle. |
| Member experience | Member benefits in Shopify new customer accounts. Test each configured benefit as a member. | Member portal; customer accounts compatibility listed. |
| In-store and email workflows | Shopify POS and Klaviyo integrations. | POS and Klaviyo compatibility listed. Verify the required plan and workflow. |
Appstle feature references: official Shopify App Store listing. A feature needing confirmation is not marked as unavailable. Test the particular rules, integration events and account experience you need in each app; a compatibility listing does not establish identical behavior.
Use one realistic benefit bundle to compare apps
For example, a fictional VIP program might charge a monthly fee, offer a member discount and award cashback on eligible purchases. Check whether the discount and reward apply to the intended products, how refunds affect the reward, where members see their credit, and what happens when membership ends.
With Memberply, start with the store credit program guide and cashback calculator. The calculator estimates rewards and alternative redemption costs; it does not prove that cashback creates additional sales.
For each app, ask for a demonstration of your exact bundle. Compare the number of steps for the merchant and member, the recurring app cost, and any extra services required. This produces a more useful decision than counting feature names.
When keeping Appstle may make sense
Keep your current app when its billing, benefits and integrations already work well and the proposed change has no clear business benefit. Include staff training, rebuilding pages, member communication and testing in the cost of switching.
If a lower-priced Appstle plan covers your needs, compare that actual plan with Memberply. If your store depends on a particular integration or a custom workflow, verify the replacement before making a commitment.
Switching from Appstle Memberships to Memberply
Start with a migration review using your current tiers, active members, renewal dates, outstanding benefits and billing arrangements. Contact Memberply to confirm the supported route for your store before cancelling the existing setup.
- Map tiers and benefits. Record prices, billing intervals, eligibility, discounts, credit rules and integrations. Decide which rules to retain or change.
- Separate member data from payments. Memberply supports CSV member imports of up to 500 records per file. Importing member records does not transfer payment mandates or cancel billing in the previous system.
- Plan recurring payment setup. Confirm whether members need to complete checkout, when any charge occurs and how existing paid-through dates will be honored. Coordinate the old and new billing so members are not charged twice.
- Reconcile benefits and member access. Confirm the handling of outstanding credit, points and access separately from the CSV import. Test new customer accounts, storefront messaging and required integrations.
- Test a small group before switching everyone. Verify sign-in, benefits, renewal, cancellation and communications. Agree the cutover and member instructions before disabling the previous setup.
See Memberply’s member import documentation for supported fields and payment-setup behavior. The presence of an import feature is not a promise of automatic transfer from Appstle.
Appstle Memberships and Appstle Subscriptions are different comparisons
This page compares membership programs. If your requirement is recurring delivery of physical products, evaluate that delivery and subscription workflow separately. A membership fee that unlocks perks has different operational requirements from replenishment orders.
Read membership apps vs subscription apps before choosing a replacement. Do not assume that a membership comparison establishes support for your subscription-box or product-delivery setup.
Questions about Appstle Memberships alternatives
What does Memberply cost compared with Appstle at 500 or 750 members?
At the listed monthly prices, Appstle Business covers up to 500 members per month for $39, while Business Premium covers up to 750 for $79. Memberply Growth is $49 with unlimited members. Required features can change the Appstle plan you need; verify how members are counted and any custom terms.
What is an alternative to Appstle Memberships for Shopify?
Memberply is an option for merchants building membership tiers with benefits such as store credit, discounts, free shipping and reward points. Compare the exact benefit rules, pricing and integrations your store needs before choosing.
Is Memberply cheaper than Appstle Memberships?
It depends on the plan and requirements. Memberply Growth is $49 per month with unlimited members. Some Appstle plans have a lower monthly app price. Compare the current member allowance and required features rather than assuming either app is always cheaper.
Does Memberply charge a transaction fee?
Memberply charges no app transaction fee on membership revenue. Its monthly app subscription is separate from Shopify charges, payment-processing fees and the cost of the benefits you offer.
Can I migrate members from Appstle to Memberply?
Memberply supports CSV member imports, but an import does not transfer payment mandates or cancel existing billing. Confirm the member data, renewal dates, payment setup and outstanding benefits with support before switching.
Does this comparison cover Appstle Subscriptions?
No. It focuses on Appstle Memberships and membership benefits. Recurring product delivery requires a separate review of subscription and fulfillment requirements.
Which customer accounts should Memberply members use?
Use Shopify new customer accounts for the Memberply member experience. Test sign-in, benefit eligibility and credit redemption with your configured tiers before launch.
Where can I read reviews of both apps?
Read the merchant reviews on each app’s official Shopify App Store listing. Look for stores with similar programs and recent comments about setup, support and the workflows you need. This comparison is published by Memberply and is not an independent review.
Read Appstle Memberships reviews and Memberply reviews.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Need a membership app focused on benefits?
Try your membership benefit bundle with Memberply’s 14-day app trial. Growth is $49 per month with unlimited members. If you are switching, confirm the migration plan first.