Reward measurement

Loyalty program breakage: how much store credit goes unused?

You issued $10,000 in loyalty credit and shoppers spent $6,000. Before calling the other $4,000 breakage, check how much customers can still use.

Illustrative credit worksheet grouping one batch into redeemed, available and expired rewards

Trusted by Shopify merchants

One batch of credit, three different outcomes

Loyalty program breakage is the portion of issued rewards customers ultimately never redeem. An expiry gives you an observable outcome. A balance that remains available has an uncertain outcome. Track the two separately.

Imagine a retailer issues $10,000 of promotional credit in January, with a mix of expiry dates. At the June review, every dollar in that January batch has one of three statuses. This example assumes one currency and no reversals or adjustments.

Status of a sample $10,000 credit cohort
Status at reviewCredit valueShare issued
Redeemed$6,00060%
Still available$3,00030%
Expired unused$1,00010%

Observed expired share = expired unused value ÷ originally issued value. Here that is $1,000 ÷ $10,000 = 10%. Counting all $4,000 unspent would produce 40%, even though customers can still use $3,000. If another $2,000 is spent and the remaining $1,000 expires, the batch closes at 80% redeemed and 20% expired.

How to measure breakage for your store

Choose one reward type, issue period and currency. Start with promotional credit issued in January. Separate refund credit, purchased gift cards and points with different redemption terms. Keep a record of each grant, its issue date, original value and expiry where applicable.

Pick a review date. Match spending and expiry to grants from that issue period. Record reversals, restored credit and manual adjustments separately so the totals reconcile. If your report only shows account balances, label the amount you cannot allocate and avoid guessing which grant was spent.

Shopify uses the credit expiring first when several credits in the same account have different expiry dates. A later order can therefore consume an earlier grant. Use the transaction history and the store’s timezone when reconciling dated credits. Shopify store credit documentation.

What is a good breakage rate?

A useful comparison is the same offer at the same age. Compare two monthly signup-credit groups 90 days after each was issued. A 30-day birthday credit and a credit with no expiry have different opportunities for redemption, so a single industry average tells you little about either offer.

If expiry rises, check the customer journey. Could a member find their balance, sign in at checkout and use the credit on something they wanted? Test one change, such as a reminder that gives the balance and an eligible purchase example. Compare the next group at the same age and check repeat purchases alongside redemption.

Frequently asked questions

Is unused credit always breakage?

Available credit can still be redeemed. Report it as outstanding and revisit the same grants at a later review date.

Can I calculate breakage as one minus the redemption rate?

Only for a closed group where all value has either been redeemed or expired and adjustments are reconciled. For an open group, that calculation also counts spendable credit.

How should I handle credit with no expiry?

Track its age and subsequent redemption separately. Label any forecast as an estimate and keep it distinct from observed expirations. The example measures customer reward use and does not calculate accounting income.

Merchant reviews

Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs

Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.

★★★★★

"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."

Olverum Official Store

United Kingdom

★★★★★

"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."

Puzzery

Canada

★★★★★

"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."

Elemental Outfit AR

Argentina

Model your next credit offer

Enter one issuance group and a consistent reporting window to explore how much credit shoppers redeem.

Use the store credit calculator