Loyalty campaigns
How to run a Shopify loyalty campaign in four weeks
Would a $5 credit bring customers back sooner, or simply pay for orders you would have received anyway? Set aside a comparison group before you send the offer and you can estimate the difference.

Trusted by Shopify merchants
A four-week campaign for a quiet trading period
Imagine a shop selling refillable products. It wants one more profitable order from existing buyers whose usual refill date has passed. In this example the merchant can fund at most $500 in issued credit. One hundred offers at $5 each use that entire allowance. Marketing and staff costs need their own budget.
| When | What to do | What to record |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1 · Plan | Pick customers with two prior orders who usually reorder in 30 days and last bought 35–55 days ago. Randomly assign 100 to receive the offer and 100 to comparison. | Freeze both lists, check contact permissions and record the usual order contribution. |
| Week 2 · Launch | Issue $5 once to each offer recipient. Explain eligible purchases, how to redeem and the closing date. Leave regular service and existing member benefits in place for both groups. | Record successful issuance and failed deliveries. Keep buyers in their originally assigned groups. |
| Week 3 · Remind | Send one reminder to eligible recipients with unused credit. Suppress opt-outs and people who have already redeemed. | Check expiry dates and balances before sending. Record message costs. |
| Week 4 · Close | End the pilot on the stated date. Compare both groups over exactly the same period, including customers who spent nothing. | Reconcile final orders, refunds and actual redeemed credit after the return window. |
Keep the offer and the test groups separate
Give the offer group an incremental benefit you can issue to that list alone. Use your credit and messaging tools to test issuance, sign-in, redemption and the reminder with a test customer. Keep a simple ledger of recipient, amount, issue date, expiry and amount used. Follow the expiry rules that apply to your store and reward type.
For ongoing member rewards, Memberply Loyalty Drops schedules credit for eligible members of a configured paid tier. The randomized audience and reminder in this example are merchant-run steps. Enabling a tier-wide reward would also reach eligible comparison customers on that tier. Review Loyalty Drops settings.
Did the extra orders cover the credit?
Suppose the offer group places 25 orders and the comparison group places 17. At equal group sizes, that is an estimated eight additional orders. If contribution averages $18 per order after variable costs and before campaign credit, those orders contribute $144. Twenty customers redeemed $5, so subtract $100. After $20 in messaging and staff costs, the pilot contributed an estimated $24.
At $18 per extra order, seven extra orders would cover the $120 campaign cost. Six would leave a loss. If your margins vary, compare actual total contribution per assigned customer in each group, counting the incentive only once. Allow for late refunds and check the next buying cycle for orders pulled forward. A small positive result warrants another test before a wider rollout. Review loyalty program KPIs.
Frequently asked questions
How much should I budget for a store credit campaign?
Multiply the number of eligible recipients by the maximum credit each can receive, then budget separately for delivery and staff time. Reserve for full redemption even when you expect some credit to go unused.
What if my comparison group is a different size?
Compare contribution per assigned customer over the same dates. Multiply the difference by the size of the offer group to estimate the campaign contribution, then deduct campaign costs that have not already been counted.
Does every loyalty campaign need a discount?
No. You can run a similar test with early access or an invitation. Use the same audience rules and count the actual fulfillment costs of the benefit.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Turn a successful test into a member benefit
If the pilot earns enough to cover its costs, test whether scheduled credit works across more than one buying cycle.
Explore scheduled member credit