Withfriends vs Memberply

A Withfriends alternative for Shopify bookstore memberships

What does a reader get for $20 a month? A discount at the counter, a seat at an author reading and a book in the mail each ask something different of your store.

Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.

Memberply publishes this comparison. See both providers’ listings below.

Bookstore counter with a membership card, event ticket and book wrapped for mailing

Trusted by Shopify merchants

What are your readers joining?

A supporters’ club

A reader pays dues to support the shop and receive benefits. Memberply suits a Shopify bookstore that wants to set its own tiers, offer member discounts and invite eligible readers to events. Withfriends also offers member discounts and adds hands-on onboarding, campaign-style membership drives and membership offers during ticket sales. Consider how much of your enrollment comes through those channels.

A book-of-the-month subscription

Withfriends lists shipping and in-store pickup for curated book clubs. If your promise is a particular title delivered every month, trial a full delivery cycle: choose the edition, reserve stock, create orders and handle address changes. Memberply’s monthly free product is a benefit a member claims. An automatic shipment needs its own order and fulfillment workflow.

What does a $20 club cost for 100 readers?

Assume 100 readers each pay US$20 in one month, for $2,000 collected. These are illustrative app fees before payment processing, Shopify charges, book inventory, packaging, postage and staff time.

Withfriends supporters’ memberships

The Shopify listing quotes $50 per month plus 20% of membership revenue. In this example, $50 + $400 = $450. The listing says the monthly fee is waived for American Booksellers Association members, which would bring the example to $400.

Withfriends book subscriptions

For $2,000 classified entirely as subscription revenue, the listed share is 10%. That gives $250 including the $50 base, or $200 with the base waived. If dues include both perks and books, ask Withfriends how your specific offer is classified before budgeting. Withfriends pricing and features on Shopify.

Memberply supporters’ memberships

Growth is US$49 per month with unlimited members and no Memberply transaction fee. Budget separately for any shipping software, ticketing services or membership-drive support your shop will retain. For a mailed club, include the cost of sourcing, packing and sending 100 books before setting the reader price. Memberply plan details.

Try the offer on the night of an author reading

Give a test reader an active membership and put an eligible $30 title through checkout. For an illustrative 10% discount, the book should ring up at $27 before tax. Check an excluded title and a nonmember purchase too. If your promise covers the shop floor, repeat the test at the register your staff use.

Then reserve one seat. Withfriends offers embedded event ticketing with membership upsells. In Memberply, choose a member event with a direct RSVP or a Shopify ticket product. Even a $0 ticket goes through checkout. Walk the reader from invitation to confirmation, then have a bookseller locate the booking at the door.

Before the next renewal or shipment

For one reader, record the paid-through date, next charge, unused benefits, upcoming event bookings and any book already promised. Confirm who can charge the next renewal and whether the reader must authorize payment again.

Test a mailed subscription and a pickup separately. Track who creates the next order, who reserves the copy and which message tells the reader it has shipped or is ready. Give existing readers a short handover note explaining their next charge, how to use their discount and where to find tickets they already hold.

Bookstore membership questions

Does Withfriends charge the same rate for dues and book subscriptions?

Its Shopify listing gives a 20% share for membership revenue and a 10% share for subscription revenue such as book-of-the-month sales. Ask how a bundled offer will be classified.

Can a bookstore host a member reading with Memberply?

Yes. An eligible reader can respond to an RSVP event or complete Shopify checkout for a free or paid event ticket, depending on how you set up the reading.

Does a monthly book benefit automatically mail a book?

Memberply’s monthly free product gives active members a product to claim. If your offer promises automatic delivery, verify how the recurring order, inventory reservation and shipment will be created.

Merchant reviews

Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs

Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.

★★★★★

"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."

Olverum Official Store

United Kingdom

★★★★★

"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."

Puzzery

Canada

★★★★★

"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."

Elemental Outfit AR

Argentina

Test your Shopify membership experience

Start with one tier and a clear benefit. Test both the customer journey and the staff workflow during your eligible 14-day trial.

Install on Shopify