Toki vs Memberply
A Toki alternative for Shopify paid memberships
Keep the perks your members paid for. Compare a $20 renewal, the cost at your store’s order volume and what happens to points, wallet passes and reviews if you move your club.
Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.
Memberply publishes this comparison. See both providers’ listings below.

Trusted by Shopify merchants
When does moving the paid club make sense?
If members mainly pay for store credit, discounts or access to a private collection, Memberply can deliver those benefits on Shopify. Start with the promise on your signup page: what will the customer receive after their next payment?
If your free rewards program feeds the paid club, first trace how the two work together. Toki can run spendable points alongside paid tiers and supports wallet passes and reviews. A shopper who joins for double points may care more about keeping that balance than about where the next membership charge comes from. See Toki’s program options.
Follow one $20 renewal through checkout
On Toki
Toki describes deposit-style offers and a separate cashback perk based on what a member spends, credited at renewal. A $20 membership price alone does not tell you the reward. Read the tier’s rule and compare it with one renewal and its credit history. Toki’s membership guide.
On Memberply
Suppose a shopper starts with $8 in native Shopify credit. An eligible USD $20 renewal with fee-to-store-credit adds $20, bringing the balance to $28. If the shopper signs in and applies $12 to a later order, $16 remains. With legacy customer accounts, members receive discount codes in the portal instead.
For a club that charges annually and gives members a fixed monthly amount, use scheduled credit through Loyalty Drops. Check that the first grant date and access period match the offer before selling it.
Compare app fees at your order volume
Both apps have a $49 starting point for paid memberships. Toki Pay as you Go includes 1,000 monthly orders. At 1,600 billable orders, its published price is $49 + (600 × $0.15) = US$139 per month. At 800 billable orders the same plan is $49. Use the order count Toki bills for your store when running this comparison.
Memberply Growth is US$49 per month for unlimited members with no Memberply transaction fee. In the 1,600-order example, the difference in app fees is $90. Include any separate wallet, reviews or loyalty tools you would keep, along with implementation and payment costs, before estimating savings. Toki’s Shopify listing · Memberply pricing.
What happens to the rest of the loyalty program?
Points, credit and outstanding rewards
Choose a test member who has both points and an unused reward. Record point units, Shopify credit by currency, outstanding codes and expiry dates separately. After setup, redeem one reward and check the remaining balance. Reissuing a reward that still works can give a member the same benefit twice.
Wallet passes and reviews
Open an existing pass, check where it links and test the in-store workflow. Identify who maintains the pass after cutover. For reviews, verify export access and where existing reviews will display. Budget for any services you keep alongside Memberply.
Renewals and the member handover
Confirm with both providers who can bill the next renewal and whether a member needs to authorize payment again. Test a successful renewal, failed payment and cancellation. Tell each member where to sign in, which balance they can spend and the date of their next charge.
Toki alternative questions
Does a $20 renewal always earn $20 in credit?
With Memberply, an eligible $20 renewal returns $20 when fee-to-store-credit is enabled and the currencies match. Toki describes several reward rules. Check the earning basis configured for your paid tier.
Does switching the paid club move my shoppers’ points?
Map each point balance to its earning history and redemption terms. Confirm what can be exported and how outstanding rewards will be honored before closing the original program.
Which Toki plan supports paid memberships?
Toki lists advanced paid membership plans under Pay as you Go, starting at US$49 per month. The plan includes 1,000 monthly orders and charges $0.15 per additional order.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Test your Shopify membership experience
Start with one tier and a clear benefit. Test both the customer journey and the staff workflow during your eligible 14-day trial.
Install on Shopify