Subscribfy vs Memberply
A Subscribfy alternative for Shopify paid memberships
If customers pay a membership fee to spend later, compare when each app issues credit, how shoppers redeem it and what each renewal costs your store.
Memberply Growth: US$49/month. 14-day trial for eligible new subscriptions.
Memberply publishes this comparison. See both providers’ listings below.

Trusted by Shopify merchants
Which app fits your membership?
When the membership is the product
Consider Memberply for a paid club built around store credit, member pricing or exclusive collections. A refill shop could charge $20 monthly and return each paid fee as credit. A shop selling a six-month pass could instead charge once and release a fixed amount each month.
When the next shipment is the product
Subscribfy supports subscription boxes and subscribe-and-save orders alongside paid memberships. If shoppers skip shipments, swap products or use branded wallet passes, include those workflows in your trial. Price any tools you would retain to deliver those services.
What triggers the credit?
For a recurring club, fee-to-store-credit ties the reward to a successful membership payment. For a prepaid pass, Loyalty Drops follows a schedule. For example, a $100 pass could deliver six $20 grants. Budget for the full $120 shoppers can redeem. See the prepaid membership walkthrough.
Check the account experience too. With Shopify customer accounts and store credit enabled, a signed-in Memberply customer can spend the balance at checkout. With legacy accounts, the member receives a discount code in their portal. Test the experience your customers actually use.
What would 200 monthly renewals cost?
Subscribfy Starter is free for up to 100 active subscribers and lists no transaction fee. A small club within that allowance may have the lowest app bill on Starter. Memberply Growth costs US$49 per month for unlimited members with no Memberply transaction fee. Advanced costs $149 per month and adds API access.
For a larger club, suppose 200 members each successfully renew once at $20. That is $4,000 in membership payments. The examples below use USD and membership transaction rates from the Shopify listings.
Subscribfy
Subscriptions plan: $49 + 1.49% of $4,000 + 200 × $0.49 = $206.60. On Pro Membership the same calculation uses $199, 1.49% and $0.25, totaling $308.60. On Elite Memberships it uses $499, 1.25% and $0.19, totaling $587. Product subscription transactions have their own rate.
Memberply
Growth: $49 for the same month. Add Shopify and payment processing charges, the cost of fulfilling redeemed credit and any separate subscription or retention tools to your own budget. Compare the features you rely on before choosing a plan.
Check current plans on the Subscribfy listing and the Memberply pricing page.
Before moving a paying member
1. Reconcile one real member journey
For a controlled test account, record the tier, next billing date, billing currency, credit already issued, amount spent and remaining balance. Find out which system owns the payment agreement and ask both providers how the next charge will be handled.
2. Prove one renewal and one redemption
Test enrollment, a successful renewal, a failed payment and cancellation. Confirm that a successful renewal produces the expected grant once. Redeem part of the balance and check what remains. Run a separate order test for any physical subscription products.
3. Explain the handover to members
Tell members where to sign in, what balance they should see and when their next charge is due. Keep the original records available while you verify the first billing cycle. Agree on which system will bill each member before enabling renewals.
Subscribfy alternative questions
Can a monthly membership fee become Shopify store credit?
Yes. On an eligible Memberply recurring tier, fee-to-store-credit returns the successful payment amount. A $20 renewal in the same currency issues $20 in credit. A free renewal issues no fee credit.
Can members pay once and receive credit monthly?
Yes. A one-time Memberply membership can issue fixed amounts through Loyalty Drops. Choose the first grant date, interval and number of grants, then test the schedule against the membership access period.
What happens to existing Subscribfy balances when I switch?
Identify where each balance lives before importing members. Reconcile Shopify account balances, outstanding codes and any app-managed rewards separately. Verify a test customer can spend the correct remaining amount before opening enrollment.
Merchant reviews
Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs
Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.
"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."
Olverum Official Store
United Kingdom
"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."
Puzzery
Canada
"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."
Elemental Outfit AR
Argentina
Test your Shopify membership experience
Start with one tier and a clear benefit. Test both the customer journey and the staff workflow during your eligible 14-day trial.
Install on Shopify