Coffee shop loyalty apps

Best Loyalty Apps for Coffee Shops Using Shopify POS

Would your regulars rather earn their tenth coffee free or pay for member prices on drinks and beans? Compare three Shopify apps from the morning queue to the next online order.

Memberply Growth: US$49/month. Unlimited members. 14-day free trial.

Memberply prepared this comparison from the providers’ published listings and setup guides.

Illustration of a café rewards card beside a cappuccino and a bag of coffee beans

Trusted by Shopify merchants

Which app fits the promise on your counter sign?

Punchy is the closest fit for a paper stamp card going digital. LoyaltyLion suits a café that wants drinks and online purchases to build a points balance. Memberply suits a roaster selling access to member prices. Start with the promise a barista can explain in one sentence.

Coffee loyalty offers and monthly app costs
AppOffer to tryPlan to budget for
PunchyBuy nine eligible drinks and get a standard drink free.Starter is free up to 30 orders per month. Growth lists unlimited orders at US$24.99/month. Punchy’s Shopify listing.
LoyaltyLionLet customers earn points on eligible purchases and choose a reward.POS requires Classic or above. Classic lists US$199/month. Confirm location coverage and get a quote above 500 monthly orders. LoyaltyLion pricing.
MemberplySell a monthly coffee pass with member pricing on eligible items.Growth lists US$49/month with unlimited members. Allow separately for Shopify POS Pro if selling recurring passes at the till. Memberply pricing.

Punchy for “buy nine coffees, get the tenth free”

On the first visit, identify the shopper in Shopify POS and ring up the eligible coffee. Staff can see the digital card in the POS tile. Choose a stamp per qualifying product if buying two coffees should count twice. A stamp per order would give that same purchase one stamp.

Once the shopper has nine qualifying stamps, add the eligible reward drink and apply the available reward from the tile. Before printing your sign, ring up a large latte with oat milk. Decide whether the upgrade is covered, and check that redeeming the free drink does not earn another paid-drink stamp.

Punchy supports the same card online and at the counter. If only prepared drinks count, buy a bag of beans online with the same customer account and confirm the stamp count holds. If beans should count, set the product rule accordingly. Punchy’s Shopify listing.

LoyaltyLion for regulars who also buy beans

Attach the customer to the POS cart before taking payment. A purchase rule can earn points from the order. On a later visit, add the customer and drink, open the Loyalty and rewards tile, choose an available reward and apply it before payment. Enable POS as a channel for that reward. LoyaltyLion’s POS guide.

A points threshold can reward a mix of coffees and beans. If the sign promises nine drinks, test whether two drinks with different prices earn exactly what you promised. For a free product added directly to the cart with points, LoyaltyLion documents the seamless version on Advanced and above. Ask about the voucher option on your plan. Free product reward requirements.

For the web order, sign in as the same customer and buy a bag of beans. Check the earning rule, then look up the balance at the till. If the reward is a drink available only at the café, show the customer where they can claim it.

Questions before choosing a café loyalty app

Which app should I try for a digital coffee punch card?

Start with Punchy if your promise is a free drink after a fixed number of qualifying drinks. Test two drinks in one transaction to check whether the card counts items or orders.

Can I sell a monthly pass online and recognize members in my café?

Memberply supports online membership signup and active-member recognition in Shopify POS. Staff select the customer in the cart and check the eligible member discount before payment.

How do I compare the cost of the offers?

For a free drink, budget for ingredients and any sale the redemption replaces. For a paid pass, compare dues collected with discounts actually used. Include app fees, POS location costs and any paid plan required for your chosen reward.

For more offer ideas, see the coffee membership guide. For a wider retail shortlist, compare Shopify POS loyalty apps.

Merchant reviews

Merchants use Memberply to launch practical membership programs

Read what merchants say about using Memberply for their membership programs. Read reviews on the Shopify App Store.

★★★★★

"The app is great and does exactly what i need it to. It is well priced and Doug is so great."

Olverum Official Store

United Kingdom

★★★★★

"Their pricing is fair, and their support is legendary."

Puzzery

Canada

★★★★★

"Our store is based in Argentina so we don't have access to Shopify Payments... Memberply solved it."

Elemental Outfit AR

Argentina

Try a paid coffee pass with Memberply

Set up a monthly tier, choose eligible drinks and beans, then check the price on one counter order and one online order during the 14-day trial.

Install on Shopify